0
SkydiveJonathan

Minimum Wage

Recommended Posts

>One of the safeguards that protects workers from the subset of companies who want
> to pay their employees next to nothing is the minimum wage.

Actually the best possible safeguard are people who refuse to work for below X dollars. (X depending on their circumstance.) Nothing else comes close. If you try to do that via a higher minimum wage, there will be more unpaid interns, fewer jobs overall, and more people being paid under the table. Result - more poverty.

Personally I think that if a company wants to pay a teenager $2 an hour to sit in a chair in a parking lot and make sure no one steals any cars, they should be able to. He can listen to his Ipod, play Angry Birds and text his friends all day. That to me is a win-win situation. I'm not sure why people want to outlaw such things.

>It makes good sense to adjust it for inflation.

You recently said we don't understand its effects. If that is the case, it would be pretty stupid to change it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

So would you like to see a temporary increase in the minimum wage until everyone gets back to "normal"?



"temporary" :D

that's cute

...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

>One of the safeguards that protects workers from the subset of companies who want
> to pay their employees next to nothing is the minimum wage.

Actually the best possible safeguard are people who refuse to work for below X dollars. (X depending on their circumstance.) Nothing else comes close. If you try to do that via a higher minimum wage, there will be more unpaid interns, fewer jobs overall, and more people being paid under the table. Result - more poverty.

Personally I think that if a company wants to pay a teenager $2 an hour to sit in a chair in a parking lot and make sure no one steals any cars, they should be able to. He can listen to his Ipod, play Angry Birds and text his friends all day. That to me is a win-win situation. I'm not sure why people want to outlaw such things.



It would be great if labor was sold in a fair, open market that allowed buyers and sellers to easily identify one another and negotiate from equal positions of power. That's not the world we live in though. Buyers of labor have a huge advantage in the market. Sometimes people have to take the jobs they can find while they look for something more appropriate. The minimum wage offers a minimal amount of protection to workers in such situations.

Quote

>It makes good sense to adjust it for inflation.

You recently said we don't understand its effects. If that is the case, it would be pretty stupid to change it.



Subsequently, I did more research, and found that the studies concluding that raising minimum wage had a negative effect on employment were subject to significant publication selection bias.
In the minimum wage literature, the magnitude of the publication selection bias is as large or larger, on average, than the underlying reported estimate. Overall, correcting for publication bias would transform a modestly negative average elasticity to a small positive employment elasticity.
So, apparently we understand the effects better than I thought. That those effects don't align with your pet political theories isn't my concern.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>Sometimes people have to take the jobs they can find while they look for
>something more appropriate.

Great. We should let them do that, not try to legislate that their first job is more appropriate.

Let's go back to my previous example. An 18 year old kid living at home with his parents. They tell him "get a job you lazy bum!" He reluctantly goes forth to find the easiest possible job he can find, one that won't interfere with his gaming, texting or phone conversations.

What would be your idea of a minimum "living wage" for a kid living at home?

>Subsequently, I did more research . . . .

and lo and behold you found a study that supported your political beliefs! That's great. I've looked at about a dozen and I think they indicate that:

-increasing minimum wages, in general, do not reduce poverty
-increasing minimum wages, in general, reduce unemployment overall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

But the fact is, no matter how low the minimum wage is, there will always be somebody who wants to push it lower "to create jobs."

It's bullshit.

In the industry I work in, there are people willing to work for nothing and other people willing to take advantage of it. It's completely illegal, but goes on all the time. I think it's ridiculous, but the concept of the unpaid intern is entrenched.



In this industry it happens a lot as well. They get past it with the school credit stuff, just like other industries.

But the small franchise owned fast food shop had to make a decision. Slower service with less employees, to make ends meet.

Matt
An Instructors first concern is student safety.
So, start being safe, first!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

>Sometimes people have to take the jobs they can find while they look for
>something more appropriate.

Great. We should let them do that, not try to legislate that their first job is more appropriate.



No one is trying to legislate that their first job is appropriate. A minimum wage job rarely is.

Quote

and lo and behold you found a study that supported your political beliefs!


No. I found a couple meta-analyses of minimum wage studies that revealed significant publication selection bias in previous work analyzing the effect of minimum wage on employment. Further, the data did not support conclusions of minimum wage increases having a negative effect on employment.

Quote

I've looked at about a dozen and I think they indicate that:
-increasing minimum wages, in general, reduce unemployment overall



That's consistent with the Doucouliagos & Stanley meta-analysis that I previously quoted, as well as work by Dube & Reich and Card & Krueger.

What is wrong with reducing unemployment?
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Quote

Snce you started this topic... what is your opinion?


Chuck



The minimum wage should be increased.



No!


Chuck



Why not? Simply mandate that every job pays at least $100 an hour and EVERYONE is happy! Workers have bunches of money, the tax base is sufficient to cover our expenses - what's the down side?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Snce you started this topic... what is your opinion?


Chuck



The minimum wage should be increased.


No!


Chuck


Why not? Simply mandate that every job pays at least $100 an hour and EVERYONE is happy! Workers have bunches of money, the tax base is sufficient to cover our expenses - what's the down side?


For a hunnerd bucks an hour... I'll take one of those jobs! Then, I could afford health and dental insurance! Yeah, like that's gonna happen![:/]


Chuck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dam straight, now there's some change we can believe in.

I propose the govt. keep 40% of every dollar it prints to pay for our healthcare, military etc. that way we can eliminate the IRS. or any other middlemen like accountants who skim off government money. Why is it necessary to earn money the government prints, only to have them take it back after it's earned?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Snce you started this topic... what is your opinion?


Chuck



The minimum wage should be increased.



No!


Chuck



Yes!




Brrrraaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaappp Wrong Answer!!

Have you considered the 'small business' that is gradually growing. Help is needed but the business owner can't quite afford $12.00 -$25.00 an hr. He can get help at minnimum wage. As his business grows, he can afford raises and so it goes. The economy grows.


Chuck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The problem with minimum wages is that it doesn't guarantee that anybody will have a job at that wage. It just says that you can't have a job for less than that. It's a pretty fine distinction, but an important one. What it means ultimately is that if the work you do isn't worth that pay, your job will disappear or move elsewhere, where it can be done more cheaply. I'm not entirely sure that really helps anyone.

If the cost of paying a worker more can be passed on to consumers, then a business will do so, and your dollar will buy less. If, on the other hand, people are unwilling to pay, say $20 for a basket of strawberries, instead, those strawberries will be imported from somewhere where they can be grown more cheaply than where a worker needs to be paid $10 an hour to pick them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

What it means ultimately is that if the work you do isn't worth that pay, your job will disappear or move elsewhere, where it can be done more cheaply.



The data suggest that doesn't actually happen.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

The problem with minimum wages is that it doesn't guarantee that anybody will have a job at that wage. It just says that you can't have a job for less than that. It's a pretty fine distinction, but an important one. What it means ultimately is that if the work you do isn't worth that pay, your job will disappear or move elsewhere, where it can be done more cheaply. I'm not entirely sure that really helps anyone.

If the cost of paying a worker more can be passed on to consumers, then a business will do so, and your dollar will buy less. If, on the other hand, people are unwilling to pay, say $20 for a basket of strawberries, instead, those strawberries will be imported from somewhere where they can be grown more cheaply than where a worker needs to be paid $10 an hour to pick them.



Studies have shown that an increase in the minimum wage doesn't lead to an increase in unemployment. So this would be a real 'trickle up' economic boost rather than a ficticious 'trickle down'.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>What it means ultimately is that if the work you do isn't worth that pay, your job will
>disappear or move elsewhere, where it can be done more cheaply. I'm not entirely
>sure that really helps anyone.

Well, it certainly helps the people in the place the job moves to. If you can get three people in an Indian call center for the price of one person in the US it becomes an easy decision for a cash-strapped business - and a very good deal for the people in New Delhi that are hired.

(Of course, the person who is let go in the US may not agree.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Then businesses will relocate of their services overseas and that will give the leftists something to whine about. Funny how they like to complain about problems their policies create.



Surely those worthy, wealthy "JOB CREATORS" wouldn't stoop to be job destroyers.

(Oh yes, they certainly would. Then they stash their extra cash in the Cayman Islands.)
...

The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0