0
leadgenx

SWS Fire container - need your opinion

Recommended Posts

Hi,

A friend of mine is thinking about SWS Fire container.
http://www.swsrigs.com/products/fire/

I am trying to get owner opinions about this rig. If you are using one - please post here what you think of it.
Free speech includes the right not to listen, if not interested.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Tested by TSO standards does not mean certified. "Airtec certified" means you may safely use cypres in that rig. FAA TSO certification cost crazy amount of money for a rig manufacturer.



I was wondering the same thing, tested to those conditions as opposed to the FAA buying off on it. They can likely sell all of them they can make in Russia and other neighbor countries without needing to go after the US market. Saying it is tested to the TSO is a way of giving some confidence to buyers. There is probably some US govt listing of equipment that has been approved per the TSO.
People are sick and tired of being told that ordinary and decent people are fed up in this country with being sick and tired. I’m certainly not, and I’m sick and tired of being told that I am

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi lead,

I cannot open your linked pdf, so I cannot see what it says.

Last year Alexey and I spent a lot of time working together on two possibilities for his company to obtain a TSO, neither were successful.

At the end of the day ( so to speak ), the FAA will got grant a TSO to any company located in the Ukraine. It has to do with bilateral agreements ( between the US & Ukraine ) that do not exist.

At least that was the last info provided by a contact in the Seattle Aircraft Certification Office.

None of this means that SWS does build a good rig; I have no knowledge of their rigs.

JerryBaumchen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ref TSO, this is from SWS

General answer to the question ‘Why SWS still does not have TSO’

After having completed our Fire container design we were planning to obtain the most exact certificate of those that were available at that moment, which was TSO-C23d that could provide the access to the biggest market of the USA.

Considering that fact that the program of dropping/jumping tests was exceeded almost twice we did not expect any general issues. We contacted the Aircraft Certification Office (ACO) of the Federal Aviation Administration of the USA (FAA) and initiated the process of TSO obtaining.

To obtain TSO a manufacturer of skydiving gear should provide the following documents (in English):
- full description of the skydiving gear with all the designs, materials and manufacturing process description;
- service instruction;
- assembly instruction and limitations for assembly/compatibility;
- test protocols according to the relevant test program;
- service instruction/overhaul manual, specifying the limitations for damages/deteriorations to be replaced;
- System of quality control, outgoing control, and the tracking system of the materials employed.

After having initiated the procedure of the certificate obtaining we provided the gear to be analyzed, test protocols and the completed list of manufacturing documents. After the materials were approved an issue of manufacturing certification was brought up.

The manufacturer can be certified only if:
There is a permanent representative office of FAA located in the country of a gear manufacturer,
The country is a member of EASA,
There is a bilateral agreement between FAA and local aviation administration regarding the transfer of authority of manufacturing control to the local aviation authorities.

For the Ukraine:
1. We have never had a permanent representative office of FAA in the Ukraine and it seems impossible in the near future,
2. The Ukraine is not a member of EASA (and it seems impossible in the near future as it will require to recertify ALL the aviation equipment according to EASA standards),
3. There is no any bilateral agreement.

Thus, TSO obtaining for a manufacturer located in the Ukraine that managed to meet all the test requirements and provided all the necessary documents is not possible.

We may play a trick by establishing a subsidiary company in a country where manufacturing certification can be obtained and perform the final assembly there in situ. This is what was done by PD by commissioning the manufacturing in Honduras but they perform the control inspection and lines installation in the USA. But this is the American company with production located in the USA and with totally different facilities and budgets.

An attempt to do that is not so advantageous for a foreign manufacturer: after having provided all the formal documentation it may be possible to obtain TSO. However, should FAA have any doubts in validity of manufacturing on the controlled territory TSO may be withdrawn. This can cause some disturbance among the consumers of this type of equipment if suddenly their equipment is banned for employment (this is what happened to a Slovenian manufacturer of lightweight aircrafts Pipistrel).

After having considered the situation and possible results for our clients we decided not to take risks and to abandon our attempts to obtain TSO.

At the moment we are in the process of the European certificate obtaining and the procedure is almost completed.

mine arrives in a week or so ;-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Certification issues are one of those things that can act as quite a barrier to access to markets.

Even if one also understands the issue of trying to uphold a certain production standard.

It would be one thing if the US Military say had some higher standards, but it isn't vital to the national interest to prohibit Americans from jumping foreign sport skydiving gear.

The rest of the aviation world will have restrictions too depending on geography and international agreements. But it is curious to see that for example in the ASTM Light Sport Aircraft category, the popular Flight Design aircraft, which have a US distributor, are designed in Germany and built and assembled in the Ukraine.

So US citizens can fly around in a 2 place, 100hp, 140 mph aircraft built in the Ukraine.... while it seems impossible for a Ukrainian company build sport parachuting rigs that Americans could use at home.

Rules....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
At the moment we are in the process of the European certificate obtaining and the procedure is almost completed.

Beware, there is no more European certificate for sport equipements. The only European certificate you can get is from the EASA and only for EMMERGENCY type parachutes. This means your rig will not be granted to be used as sport parachute.
Jérôme Bunker
Basik Air Concept
www.basik.fr
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Le-Luc-France/BASIK-AIR-CONCEPT/172133350468

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
From one European country means only allows in this sole country. The problem in EEC is there is no agreement between each of the EEC countries. This is a mess, if you want to sell in France you must have a QAC-121, if you want to sell in Germany you need the German rigger association approval, same for BPA, etc....
If you need help for the French approval let me know.
Jérôme Bunker
Basik Air Concept
www.basik.fr
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Le-Luc-France/BASIK-AIR-CONCEPT/172133350468

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Maksimsf

Tested by TSO standards does not mean certified. "Airtec certified" means you may safely use cypres in that rig. FAA TSO certification cost crazy amount of money for a rig manufacturer.



That's what I was thinking. This is what some of the other manufactuers say.

Sparky

The Stellar line of reserves was tested
with the Quasar II harness/container assembly,
and is approved by the FAA to TSO
C23c, Category B.


The JAVELIN harness/container system was tested in accordance with
AS-8015A and is approved by the FAA under TSO C-23c, Category B.


See attachment
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JerryBaumchen

Hi Wally,

Quote

just who much does it cost to to a complete TSO cert on a rig ?



I've had this very discussion with a number of people as of late. Personal opinion, you will need about $75K.

JerryBaumchen


The last one I was involved in was in 1998/1999. We were under contract to China Lake providing A/C, rigging, drop tests, live jumps and ground recovery. We billed them in excess of $100,000. But we paid for all the beer. B|

Sparky
My idea of a fair fight is clubbing baby seals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0